Curious Casey Tries Anal

After getting naked, straight boy Casey settles in with a porn video. Vinnie sucks on his dick, as Casey reclines in the chair, and then rubs their slippery cocks together. As Vinnie continues to stroke him, he presses his hard cock against Casey's asshole and tries to push in. Casey seems willing, but he's too tense to allow anything but the very tip of Vinnie's big cock to enter. After stroking himself for a while longer, Casey realizes he just isn't going to be able to cum. Perhaps next time things will go a little further with this curious straight boy.